top of page

France Wants to Give Police the Benefit of the Doubt. Who Gives Black Youth Theirs?

3 days ago
6 min read

"Lawmakers are advancing a presumption that police weapons use complies with the law. In a country where suspicion already falls unequally, the consequences deserve considerably more scrutiny."


by Ken Oswald "__yak" Vann, Jr.


DIMANCHE 15 novembre 2026


France has an interesting relationship with the benefit of the doubt. Apparently, it depends on who’s holding the gun.


Assa Traoré in a black “Justice pour Adama” T-shirt, with braided hair and other march participants behind her.
 Assa Traoré at the Marche pour Adama in Persan, July 21, 2018. Families were demanding accountability long before this bill reached Parliament.

A young Black man can be required to establish his identity without having committed a crime. Lawmakers now want police officers who use their weapons to receive an additional legal presumption that they acted lawfully. Both the officer and the young man are entitled to the presumption of innocence. The proposed advantage concerns the officer’s conduct itself. www.defenseurdesdroits.fr


The National Assembly adopted the proposal introduced by right-wing deputy Éric Pauget and colleagues on July 7. Rewritten at the government’s initiative, it cleared the Senate’s Law Committee unchanged on November 10. Senate consideration is scheduled to begin November 19, with another sitting listed for December 10. Senators should reject the presumption. Sénat


I’m a Black American artist working in France. My country’s record on police accountability gives me plenty of reasons to approach this subject with humility. It also gives me reasons to recognize an institutional arrangement that deserves a harder look. French people have been demanding that scrutiny long before I arrived.

In findings published in June 2025, the Défenseur des droits reported that young men perceived as Black, Arab, or Maghrebi were four times more likely than the rest of the population to have experienced an identity check. They were twelve times more likely to have experienced an intrusive check involving measures such as a search, pat-down, removal to a station, or an order to leave. www.defenseurdesdroits.fr


The survey covered adults aged 18–79 in metropolitan France and asked about the preceding five years. Those figures describe police encounters, not the likelihood of being shot. They establish unequal exposure to suspicion. They also describe overlapping populations whose experiences should be examined carefully rather than collapsed into one interchangeable identity. www.defenseurdesdroits.fr


Empty French Senate chamber with curved rows of red seats, wooden desks, and white statues beneath a gilded ceiling.
The French Senate’s chamber, photographed on November 14, 2017. Senators are scheduled to begin considering the proposed presumption on November 19, 2026.

When the Assembly voted in July, Assa Traoré, founder of the Adama committee, was present in the public gallery. La Dépêche reported her warning that existing police impunity was being strengthened and legitimized. Lawmakers debating public confidence should reckon with the families who have organized for years to make accountability a public demand. ladepeche.fr


That demand brings us to the mechanism behind what opponents call the permis de tuer. Article L.435-1 of the Internal Security Code restricts weapons use to specified situations and requires absolute necessity and strict proportionality. The proposed text would presume national police officers and gendarmes had met the authorized circumstances and those requirements, subject to contrary evidence. www.legifrance.gouv.fr


The presumption would be rebuttable. It would not abolish investigations or judicial oversight, and it would not automatically make an officer’s account true. Nor does the text expressly require bereaved families to conduct a prosecution. Those limits matter. So does the additional advantage: legal compliance would receive a statutory presumption of its own. senat.fr


The bill also makes a separate, limited change to weapons authorization. It removes the uniform or visible-insignia requirement in the defined circumstances involving prevention of renewed murders or attempted murders. Necessity and proportionality remain required. That provision deserves scrutiny, too; it should not be confused with the broader presumption. senat.fr


An accused officer already benefits from the presumption of innocence, as every suspect should. Guilt must be established. A presumption favoring the lawfulness of the act adds something different. Protecting an individual against unsupported punishment does not settle whether the state has adequately examined the force exercised in its name. www.legifrance.gouv.fr


Supporters have an argument worth answering. The Senate report cites 6,625 physical assaults against national police in 2024, including 1,289 involving weapons. Officers face real danger. The prospect of legal proceedings may, supporters contend, discourage justified intervention. The report also presents the measure as a way to reduce resort to police custody and provide stronger grounds for closing cases where investigations find no evidence of unlawful weapons use. www.senat.fr


Nobody should dismiss an officer’s need to act decisively to protect a life. But lawmakers should demonstrate the claimed deterrent effect and explain why clearer guidance, professional support, and prompt investigations would be insufficient. The report’s proposed procedural benefits are precisely why its assurance that scrutiny will remain intact needs testing.


An investigation can continue to exist on paper while its practical strength depends on what investigators look for, how quickly they look, and what they preserve. If a recording is overwritten before it is secured, its absence cannot tell us whether a shot was justified. If witnesses are missed, their silence tells us nothing. Evidence does not collect itself.


Under Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights, an effective investigation into an alleged unlawful killing by state agents requires sufficient independence from those implicated. It must be capable of establishing whether force was justified. Authorities must take reasonable steps to secure evidence, and the family must be involved sufficiently to protect its legitimate interests. These obligations concern the state; they do not pronounce an individual officer guilty. ks.echr.coe.int


France’s IGPN conducts judicial investigations at the request of prosecutors or investigating judges. The relevant questions concern independence in practice, investigative decisions, and access to evidence. Simply observing that investigators also work for the state does not answer those questions. www.police-nationale.interieur.gouv.fr


The OSCE’s Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights addressed the proposed law in a November 5 opinion. It warned that presumed lawfulness could narrow investigative scrutiny before facts were independently established. It also identified the difficulty of challenging official accounts when authorities hold superior or exclusive access to relevant information. The office recommended reconsidering the presumption. odihr.osce.org


The practical risk is straightforward. If authorities hold the footage, communications, and incident records, families depend on the thoroughness of the very process they may need to challenge. How will the state ensure that an absence of contrary evidence reflects a serious inquiry, rather than a failure to obtain it?


Consider Nahel Merzouk, shot dead at 17 during a traffic stop in Nanterre on June 27, 2023. In findings published in June 2026, the Défenseure des droits concluded that the fatal shot had not met the professional requirements of absolute necessity and proportionality. The authority also noted that the officers lacked body cameras and recommended their systematic use by motorized brigades. www.defenseurdesdroits.fr


Those were professional-ethics findings, not a criminal conviction. The officer maintains that his shot was lawful. A decision concerning the case’s legal classification is expected November 24. The distinction protects the accused officer’s right to due process while allowing the public to examine documented professional failures. Accountability requires both. www.defenseurdesdroits.fr


A family should not need a viral video to earn a serious investigation. The state’s obligation to establish what happened must survive the absence of a clean recording, an agreeable witness, or an account convenient enough to fit inside a television segment.


Red words “Justice pour Nahel” on a beige wall beside a Paris street, with pedestrians and a white van in the background.
“Justice pour Nahel” in Paris’s Batignolles district, photographed July 1, 2023. A family should not need a viral video to earn a serious investigation.

France has practical work available. Secure recordings and radio communications promptly. Preserve forensic evidence. Give families meaningful participation through the appropriate procedures. Publish clearer information about weapons use and case outcomes. Provide officers with training and legal support that help them act within the rules and explain their decisions afterward.


If custody is being used unnecessarily, address that practice with evidence and appropriate procedural safeguards. If investigations take too long, improve their capacity. Neither problem establishes that potentially lethal force needs a favorable presumption about its legality.


And stop treating Black citizenship as a question that must be reopened at every encounter with authority. Young Black French people already possess rights. The issue is whether institutions honor them when an officer stops them, when they challenge an account, and when a family asks how somebody died.


It is a fucked-up arrangement when the people subjected to disproportionate suspicion are asked to accept additional legal reassurance for the armed institution scrutinizing them. Public confidence requires an investigation strong enough to test the official account, protect an innocent officer, and expose unlawful conduct.


When Senate debate begins, lawmakers should reject this presumption and insist on safeguards that make accountability work. The state’s authority to use potentially lethal force demands especially rigorous examination. Families deserve a process capable of producing answers even when those answers make the institution uncomfortable.


Because when the law begins by trusting the gun, the child enters his own story as contrary evidence.

Comments


bottom of page