top of page

Black Enough to Die for France. Too Black to Belong?

7 days ago
6 min read

"France remembers Black sacrifice. Equality is still being asked for its papers."


by Ken Oswald “__yak” Vann, Jr. | The Table We Set


THURSDAY 12 November 2026


Marine Le Pen says discrimination does not exist in France. The country’s own rights watchdog has apparently been investigating without her permission.


Marine Le Pen, wearing a dark jacket and white blouse, stands behind two microphones against a blue background in Madrid in February 2025.
Marine Le Pen, Madrid, February 8, 2025. Apparently, declaring a country innocent is easier than reading its own reports.

Her November 8 CBS interview crowned France the world’s least racist country. Three days later, the Republic bowed its head for its war dead. Thousands of Africans belong to that history. The ceremony recognizes a contribution. The argument begins when recognition is expected to change how the living are treated.


Black French citizens do not need a dead soldier in the family to justify their place. Their equality is already owed. The soldiers expose a contradiction in France’s conduct; they are not witnesses required to approve somebody else’s citizenship.


On November 10, Éric Zemmour announced his 2027 presidential candidacy, proposing two million fewer immigrants over five years. His targets include legally resident foreigners unemployed for more than six months. That is a proposal concerning foreign nationals, not an enacted rule or a measure against French citizens.


Blaise Diagne and Gratien Candace, French deputies, 1921. Black political presence in France did not begin when a television panel discovered immigration.
Blaise Diagne and Gratien Candace, French deputies, 1921. Black political presence in France did not begin when a television panel discovered immigration.

Blackness establishes neither foreign nationality nor immigration status. Yet the Défenseur des droits describes young French citizens being assigned a foreign origin through appearance, names or accents. Citizenship can be settled in law while strangers keep reopening the question socially. And a foreign passport does not make discrimination acceptable.


Aïssata Seck’s campaign began with men she encountered at the market in Bondy. In a 2021 interview, she recalled their medals—and the obstacles they faced obtaining French nationality. Seck, a Black French woman whose grandfather had been a tirailleur, turned those encounters into a political demand. As Bondy’s deputy mayor in 2016, she sought responsibility for veterans and memory to pursue that fight.


She launched a petition and kept pushing for attention. Repeated follow-ups eventually secured coverage in Le Monde, published on the eve of November 11, 2016. The appeal spread to more than 60,000 signatories. On April 15, 2017, 28 former tirailleurs entered French citizenship at the Élysée. President François Hollande thanked Seck for initiating the petition.


A Senegalese soldier wearing medals stands beside a woman carrying a child on her back on a cobbled street in Marseille in January 1914.
Marseille, January 4, 1914, before the war: a Senegalese soldier beside a woman carrying a child. The uniform was never the whole life.

These were veterans of later confli cts, including Indochina and Algeria; many had lost French nationality around independence. This was not a gathering of First World War survivors. Their case crossed the legal changes of decolonization, while their medals endured.


Tell this story only as a president welcoming grateful Africans and political organizing disappears behind French hospitality. The veterans were asserting claims. A Black French woman organized public pressure. The state changed its answer.


I’m a Black American artist working in France. My country’s record gives me reason to examine declarations of national innocence closely.


The watchdog’s February 2026 report cites survey responses collected in 2019–2020. Among respondents aged 18–30 in metropolitan France who were immigrants, descendants of immigrants or born in French overseas territories, roughly a quarter reported discrimination linked to skin color, origin or nationality in the five years before their interviews.


In Île-de-France housing tests cited in the report, young working applicants perceived as from sub-Saharan Africa or overseas France had 40 percent less chance of receiving a housing offer than applicants perceived as having longstanding French origins. The applications stay comparable. The apparent origin changes. So does the answer.


For a young person trying to leave the family home, an extra refusal can mean postponing a job, accepting a longer commute or staying dependent on relatives. Not every rejection is discrimination. But an applicant sees one unanswered message; a testing program can uncover a pattern. The person has to organize a life with limited information, while the landlord controls the decision and its explanation.


Deny the discrimination, and the inequality it produces becomes evidence against the people experiencing it.


That is the political usefulness I see in reading Le Pen’s denial beside Zemmour’s employment test. Exclude discrimination from the explanation, assign responsibility entirely to the unemployed person, and removal can be advertised as the remedy. These are rival politicians. They do not need a shared campaign headquarters for their arguments to reinforce each other.


Now put those closed doors beside yesterday’s wreaths.


Roughly 200,000 tirailleurs served during the First World War; around 30,000 died. The designation “Senegalese” covered men recruited across France’s sub-Saharan colonies. Recruitment included coercion. Many served as colonial subjects rather than equal citizens; citizenship arrangements varied, including the distinct position of people from Senegal’s Four Communes.


France was not simply receiving assistance from generous outsiders. Colonial administrators governed the territories supplying those men and could demand service while withholding equal political standing. Their uniforms made them indispensable to a national undertaking without erasing the hierarchy under which they served. Honor their courage without laundering the conditions of recruitment.


Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, c. 1789. For a promise this old, equality has spent a remarkable amount of time waiting on implementation.
Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, c. 1789. For a promise this old, equality has spent a remarkable amount of time waiting on implementation.

Article 1 of the Constitution guarantees citizens equality before the law regardless of origin, race or religion. That promise supplies grounds for challenging institutions. It should reach the rental agent deciding which application gets a response. When equality becomes a reason to stop investigating inequality, the principle starts protecting the institution from examination.


Aimé Césaire makes that maneuver harder to hide. In Discours sur le colonialisme, he attacked Europe’s celebration of humanism alongside its acceptance of colonial violence against people excluded from that humanism’s protection. The proclaimed principle had a racial boundary. I read him as demanding that we follow a universal right all the way to the person it leaves outside.


Césaire helped develop Négritude in interwar Paris, insisting on Black cultural and historical self-recognition. The demand to name racial domination has a history within the French-speaking world. Treating it as a foreign intrusion would require evicting part of that world’s own intellectual record. France’s Black thinkers are not guests in an argument they helped build.


I have run kitchens. Imagine management putting the cooks in the anniversary photograph while keeping every decision upstairs. Gratitude can leave authority untouched. But citizens are not hired help in a country owned by somebody else. A Black French citizen already has a claim on the room.


The school commemorations make that claim especially immediate. A July 2 circular instituted annual ceremonies around November 11, starting at CM1. Teaching unions have warned about militarization and political instrumentalization. Yet the circular itself calls for critical historical understanding. Its own standard supports teaching coercive recruitment and unequal colonial status alongside military service.


Commemoration can challenge exclusion. Seck’s educational work makes that clear. In her 2021 interview, she described the message to pupils, translated here: “We tell pupils that they are all part of French history.” Refusing erasure and demanding present equality are compatible projects.


Let pupils ask about unequal citizenship. Explain who campaigned to change the record. What exactly is being taught if a Black child must perform gratitude before being allowed to question the nation? A republic should be able to survive its own follow-up questions.


Rejecting a rental applicant because of origin is already unlawful. Fund independent discrimination testing and legal support for complainants. Require housing and employment officials to publish findings and follow-up action. Apply the existing penalties when discrimination is proved. The government should answer for what changed after the report appeared. Enforcement needs a budget and an outcome. A tenant needs a home, not an unpaid second job proving why the door stayed closed.


For the young Black French person reading this, there should also be room for an ordinary life. You need not become a decorated soldier, a brilliant artist or the exemplary student who makes an institution feel generous. You can lose a job. You can dislike the government. Your family history need not resemble anybody else’s. None of that makes your citizenship an unfinished application.


Honor the soldiers. Enforce the rights of the living. Then stop congratulating the Republic for promises Black citizens still have to organize to collect. Black France does not owe anybody another generation of exceptional service before receiving ordinary fucking equality.



Comments


bottom of page