Hollywood Does Not Have a Movie Problem. It Has a Budget Problem.
"The summer box office isn’t dying. It’s just tired of watching studios spend the GDP of Barbados on nostalgia nobody asked for."
by Ken Oswald "__yak" Vann, Jr.
MONDAY 13 July 2026

This summer has been filled with disappointments.
Not because people stopped going to the movies. That’s the lazy explanation studios use when they don’t want to admit they spent the GDP of a small island nation on somebody wearing a cape, a helmet, or a goofy wig.
People are still going.
They’re just not automatically showing up because a studio spent $250 million and stapled a familiar logo to the poster.
The clearest example right now is Disney’s live-action Moana, which opened to $43 million domestic and $95 million worldwide against a reported $250 million production budget. That is not a disaster because $95 million is a small number. That is a disaster because the movie cost $250 million before anybody even bought commercials, bus ads, Happy Meal synergy, and whatever spiritual bribe it takes to convince audiences they needed a live-action remake of a movie that came out ten years ago.

And that’s the part that makes this whole thing feel insane. Moana 2 just crossed a billion dollars in 2024. The original Moana was still alive on Disney+. Kids were still watching it. Parents were still hearing “You’re Welcome” in their nightmares. So Disney looked at a property that was already working and said, “You know what this needs? The Rock in a wig.”
Now, let me be clear. I grew up loving The Rock. Wrestling Rock. Eyebrow Rock. “It doesn’t matter what your name is” Rock. The Rock was one of the coolest human beings alive when I was young.
But I do not need The Rock in a goofy wig doing live-action Maui like somebody dared a bouncer at Bahama Breeze to audition for community theater.
At some point we have to ask the basic question: why are studios still paying this much money for this many Dwayne Johnson vehicles that keep coming back with the financial equivalent of a pulled hamstring?
This is the recent pattern:

The problem is obvious. If a movie costs $20 million and underperforms, everybody gets a bruise. If a movie costs $250 million and underperforms, somebody needs to check the invoices twice and maybe ask why the catering budget included a moon landing. Theaters keep a major cut of box-office revenue, and marketing can add tens or hundreds of millions more, which is why a movie grossing more than its production budget can still lose money.
That’s why The Mandalorian and Grogu is such an interesting case. On paper, $340 million worldwide sounds fine. In normal human money, that is a ridiculous amount of money. But against a $165 million production budget, with marketing and theater splits, that’s not a victory parade. That’s Disney standing in the kitchen at 2 a.m. eating shredded cheese out the bag, trying to convince itself everything is fine.
Same with Supergirl. That movie has made about $115 million worldwide on a $170 million budget. That is not underperformance. That is a cape caught in the ceiling fan.
Masters of the Universe might be even worse because who exactly was begging for a $170 million He-Man movie? That’s not nostalgia. That’s a ransom note written in Mattel font. It has made about $112.6 million worldwide.
Meanwhile, the movies actually working this summer are not the ones trying to financially colonize the multiplex.
Look at the smaller-budget wins:

Obsession cost $1 million and has made over $426 million worldwide. That is not a hit. That is a bank robbery with lighting cues.
Backrooms cost $10 million and has made nearly $368 million. A weird internet horror movie from the YouTube generation just walked into theaters and made some of these legacy franchises look like Blockbuster Video gift cards.
Scary Movie cost $30 million and has grossed $228 million worldwide. Not art. Not prestige. Not a sacred cinematic object. Just a movie that understood the assignment: make people laugh, don’t spend stupid money, get out alive.
And even The Devil Wears Prada 2, which is not exactly an indie film, still proves the broader point. It cost $100 million — expensive, yes, but not “why does this invoice smell like congressional fraud?” expensive — and has reportedly performed at about 6.9 times its production budget.
So what is the simplest explanation everybody is ignoring?

Hollywood is addicted to spending money because spending money has become a substitute for having taste.
Instead of asking, “Does this story need to exist?” they ask, “Can we pre-sell this internationally?”
Instead of asking, “Does the audience care?” they ask, “Can we attach a star?”
Instead of asking, “Is this actually good?” they ask, “Can we make it look expensive enough that people assume it matters?”
That is how you get a $250 million live-action Moana less than two years after a billion-dollar animated sequel. That is how you get The Rock painted, padded, wigged, and digitally massaged into a movie nobody needed. Again, love The Rock. But at a certain point, being a fan means being honest. I loved prime Shaq too. That does not mean I needed him taking threes in 2010.
And I think The Odyssey is next.

Now, Nolan is Nolan. I respect Nolan. He is one of the few directors left who can make grown adults argue about film formats like they’re discussing theology. The Odyssey is tracking for a major opening, with forecasts around $100 million to $120 million domestic, and it has the advantage of IMAX, prestige, curiosity, and a monster cast.
But the movie reportedly cost $250 million, runs 172 minutes, is rated R, and is based on Homer. That is a lot of burden for a film that needs to be more than admired. It needs to become an event for weeks. A $100 million opening sounds great until you realize this thing likely needs something in the neighborhood of $600 million-plus worldwide to feel truly safe.
My prediction: The Odyssey will not fail because people hate it. It will fail because Hollywood has forgotten the difference between success and profitability. It might open big. It might get praised. It might dominate Film Twitter for ten days while every man with a Letterboxd account pretends he always cared deeply about Ithaca.
But if it finishes somewhere in the $500 million range, the public will call it a hit and the accountants will be somewhere in a conference room quietly chewing glass.
That’s the disease.
A movie can make half a billion dollars now and still feel like a disappointment because everybody upstream got paid like they were curing cancer.
Actors are getting paid too much. Directors are getting blank checks. IP holders are being rewarded for owning old toys. Studios are spending like they’re trying to hide money in plain sight. I’m not accusing anybody of actual money laundering. I’m just saying when every third blockbuster costs $200 million and looks like a screensaver with trauma, the question starts asking itself.
Movies should not cost this much to make.
Not every fantasy movie needs a defense budget. Not every superhero movie needs to look like a PS6 cutscene. Not every remake needs to be dragged into live action just because a corporation found an old lunchbox in the vault.
The audience is not rejecting movies.
The audience is rejecting arrogance.

They’ll show up for Obsession. They’ll show up for Backrooms. They’ll show up for Scary Movie. They’ll show up when the movie feels like somebody had an idea instead of a quarterly earnings strategy.
That’s the lesson.
Hollywood doesn’t need bigger movies.
It needs cheaper movies with better instincts.
And somebody needs to tell The Rock that we still love him.
We just don’t need him in any more wigs.




Comments